Since New York City initiated its crackdown on short-term rentals like Airbnb six months ago, finding affordable lodging has become more challenging and expensive. The number of available Airbnb listings has plummeted by over 15,000, according to an analysis by AirDNA. As a result, travelers are either wary of sharing quarters with hosts or uncertain whether their rental is even legal. Hotels, meanwhile, have taken advantage of reduced competition, raising their prices.
Rebecca Norman, who plans to visit New York from the U.K. with her family in October, found that an average hotel room with a pullout couch would cost $4,400 for a five-night stay. "I look at all these hotels, and what I want isn't at the price I want," she said.
Despite the shrinking supply, legal Airbnb hosts have seen their bookings fall, forcing them to drop rates. Several other cities facing housing shortages are watching New York's example, as Christian Klossner, the executive director of the city's Office of Special Enforcement, explained that the main goal is to uphold laws that protect both housing and residents.
With New York's restrictions, neighboring areas like Jersey City and Hoboken in New Jersey have become attractive alternatives for travelers seeking Airbnb accommodations. Since September, New York City has required short-term rental operators to obtain licenses, which led thousands of hosts to pull their listings from Airbnb. The number of Airbnb units available for less than 30 days dropped from about 21,500 in August to just 3,280 in February, according to AirDNA.
To offer a legal Airbnb listing in New York, hosts can’t rent out an entire apartment or home, and they must be present during the stay. This requirement has significantly reduced the availability of full-unit rentals. In December 2023, city hotels charged an average of $393 per night, an increase from $355 in the previous year. Comparatively, Airbnb and Vrbo listings for entire homes averaged $404 a night, while private rooms averaged $157, according to AirDNA data.
Hotel prices have risen due to a variety of factors, including reduced competition from Airbnb, the use of 16,500 hotel rooms for housing migrant arrivals, and development regulations, according to Vijay Dandapani, CEO of the Hotel Association of New York City. Yotel New York Times Square saw a boost in business through Airbnb, with a 36% increase in occupancy compared to the same period the year before.
Despite the city’s efforts, unregistered short-term listings have proliferated on third-party sites such as Craigslist and Facebook. The boom in Airbnbs began when the city faced a significant shortage of affordable rentals, leading many to list properties on Airbnb instead. Jonathan Miller, author of NYC rental reports from Douglas Elliman, noted that even with more units becoming traditional rentals, it wasn't enough to curb rent increases.
For travelers like Chris Conte, a New Jersey resident, finding affordable lodging in the city has become more challenging. Conte, who often booked Airbnb stays near concert venues, ended up splitting a $345-a-night Holiday Inn Express room in Queens after finding limited options on Airbnb. “If it’s for the happiness of the city, then so be it, we have to adjust,” he said.
Legal Airbnb hosts have had to change their strategies. Kat Casey, who owns a two-family home in Astoria, Queens, with her husband, intended to use the income from their rental unit to support maintenance costs. Under the new regulations, guests stay in a private room in a shared unit rather than a private apartment. As a result, Casey’s future bookings are down 50% from last year. “There’s a lot more cancellations, a lot more questions, and a lot more anxiety with guests than previously,” she said, noting that the regulations don't support families like hers.
Similarly, Aminah West, who previously managed multiple rental units in Brooklyn, lost significant income as owners pulled their listings post-enforcement. Though she still manages a single licensed rental, West has had to drop her nightly rate from $120 to $90 to attract guests. Despite the challenges, she remains motivated to continue hosting, viewing it as a way to connect people from around the world. “Beyond the economic case of it, I get to build a bridge to, and through, community for people around the world,” she said.
New York City's stringent regulations have reshaped the short-term rental market, creating hurdles for both visitors and hosts. With limited lodging options and soaring hotel rates, travelers and residents alike must navigate a new landscape that prioritizes housing stability over short-term convenience.
Licensed in California | Cal BRE #01349057
Company Name: Teocalli Inc
EIN: 81-3887986
548 Gibson Dr,
Roseville, CA 95678
All Rights Reserved | Hotel InnVestments | Privacy Policy | SMS Disclosure
Real Estate Web Design by Bullsai